De facto control with a 35% shareholding
A Nigerian holding company owns 35% of the voting shares of an operating company. The remaining 65% is held by approximately 2,000 unrelated individual shareholders, none holding more than 1%, with historically low and passive attendance at general meetings. The holding company has consistently been able to direct the operating company's key operating and financing decisions at shareholder meetings over several years due to the dispersion and passivity of other shareholders.
Facts
Workings
Power: despite holding only 35% of voting rights, the size of the holding relative to the size and dispersion of other shareholdings, combined with the demonstrated practical ability to direct relevant activities at shareholder meetings, indicates the holding company has de facto power over the investee.
Variable returns: the holding company is exposed to variable returns through its dividend entitlement and share of net asset value.
Link between power and returns: the holding company has consistently used its de facto power to direct the activities affecting its returns.
Conclusion: all three elements of control are met; the operating company is a subsidiary and should be consolidated despite the sub-50% shareholding.
